ECM have kept faith with Young, after ‘Evening Falls’ (released in 2004) and ‘Sideways’ (released in 2008) two albums that cultivated the guitarist’s great talent in settings that favoured bass clarinet and trumpet, but is now let grow wild to express itself more directly. Producer and label auteur Manfred Eicher must have just felt deep down that Young will deliver something that would mean that bit more, somewhere, some time, and that trust is rewarded by one of ECM’s most beautiful albums in years. With a melodicism that draws you back to the well of Miles’ modal period drawing much from the Cool School sensibility the performance is just magical, there really isn’t another word, the recorded sound by legendary engineer Jan Erik Kongshaug so very human and warm. […] Wasilewski is one of the world’s great jazz pianists and there really is something special here, the rapport between piano and guitar instant, and Seim seems to have found the playing situation that suits him at last, the freedom to be himself.
Stephen Graham, Marlbank
Guitarist Jacob Young is once again partnered by his closely attuned old friend, the delicate saxophonist Trygve Seim – but following a meeting with Marcin Wasilewski at the 2012 Oslo jazz festival, that relationship blooms in fertile new ground laid by Polish pianist Wasilewski’s brilliant trio. […] The combination of Young’s acoustic sound with the vapour trails of Seim’s gently pungent improvisations, or his rounded electric tone against Wasilewski’s probing piano figures, make this a set full of undemonstrative surprises and contrasts, and the quality of the composing matches the formidable powers of the band.
John, Fordham, The Guardian
This dream-team amalgam of Norwegian guitarist Young and saxophone partner Trygve Seim with the Polish rhythm section from the band of Tomasz Stanko creates infinitely subtle, quietly intense music. It almost seems to hover in the room, such is the sense of airy weightlessness […] The third track, ‘Bounce’, is particularly fine, but it’s all very good, and keeps getting better.
Phil Johnson, The Independent
If anything, ‘Forever Young’ provides Young with even greater freedom than on his previous ECM outings, where he was the sole chordal instrument. Here, Young recruits pianist Marcin Wasilewski’s trio—a group that, despite being on the shy side of forty, has been together for two decades and has, consequently, evolved both a chemistry and a language all its own […] For those unfamiliar with Young’s extracurricular activities, ‘Forever Young’ demonstrates an ability to simmer in a way that his previous ECM recordings did not. It also represents a first outing by a quintet with plenty of potential; hopefully six years won’t have to pass before this intimate yet delicately expressionistic quintet can once again reconvene.
John Kelman, All About Jazz
Norwegian-American guitarist Young has considerable melodic gifts, and what a wonderful group he has assembled for this his third ECM album: saxophonist Trygve Seim, pianist Marcin Wasilewski, bassist Slawormir Kurkievicz, and drummer Michael Miskiewicz. The rhythm section is, of course, Wasilewski’s celebrated trio. All the compositions are Young’s, and each piece has immense melodic strength. […] Young is featured extensively on nylon string guitar, with a lovely warm tone […] A superb collaboration.
John Watson, Jazz Camera
Wie schon frühere Young-Alben klingt auch dieses kaum nach dem Album eines Gitarristen. Dessen Stücke bestechen durch sangbare, ohrwurmartige Themen. Da diese durchweg vom Saxofon vorgestellt werden, schient weithin der Bläser mit seinem weichen Ton das Geschehen zu dominieren , dafür geben Youngs Gitarren, zusammenmit dem Klavier, von Anfang an die Atmosphäre vor. […] Im Umfeld eines Labels, bei dem wegweisende Gitarristen großgeworden sind, verfügt der Norweger mit amerikanischen Wurzeln über eine ganz eigene Stimme.
Berthold Klostermann, Stereo
‚Forever Young‘ heißt seine neue Platte mit dem Saxofonisten Trygve Seim und einem polnischen Trio um Marcin Wasilewski – und da wir diese leise, anrührende, sanft betörende CD seit Erscheinen schon etwa 40-mal angehört haben, könnte das mit der Unsterblichkeit Youngs klappen.
Wolfram Goertz, Rheinische Post
Saxophonist Trygve Seim und Jacob Young, ein Schüler von Jim Hall und John Abercrombie, kennen sich seit Jugendtagen und arbeiten immer wieder mal zusammen, sind also ein eingespieltes Team. Hinzu kommt das komplette Marcin Wasilewski Trio – und einmal mehr erweist sich, wie ergiebig doch die musikalische Polen-Norwegen-Schiene, die ja Tradition hat, sein kann.
Berthold Klostermann, Fono Forum
Guitarist Jacob Young mixes electric, acoustic and classical guitar with a subtly bopping team of Trygve Seim/ts-ss, Marcin Wasilewski/p, Slawomir Kurkiewicz/b and Michal Miskiewicz/dr through a collection of originals. The intriguing part of this disc is how easily Young can mix sounds that range from indie rock to low key bop make it all sound cohesive. […] On the acoustic side, some lovely classical guitar mixes with Seim’s low key tenor on ‘Therese’s Gate’ and some Middle Eastern moods mix with jazz on ‘Sofia’s Dance’ creating some delightful sounds. Prancing rhythms dance underneath Youngs acoustic strumming on the spaciously stated ‘Beauty’ making this a well rounded session in depth and width.
George W. Harris, Jazz Weekly
Les habitués d’ECM ne seront pas dépaysés par cet album réunissant pour la première fois trois figures du label, le guitariste norvégien Jacob Young, son compatriote saxophoniste Trygve Seim, et le trio du pianiste polonaise Marcin Wasilewski. Sans surprise la rencontre donne lieu à une musique lyrique et séduisante, aérienne et rêveuse.
Pascal Rozat, Jazz Magazine
Cette légèreté est une grâce, et ce disque en est tout nimbé. De sa Norvège natale, Young transpose donc musicalement le spleen, tout au moins une forme de mélancolie très contemplative […] Et comme rien ne semble avoir été laissé au hasard dans ce disque estampillé ECM et très emblématique de l’esthétique poéticolymphatique (ou l’inverse) du label, on a fait, pour completer l’equipe, toute confiance à un saxophonist à la fois aérien et aquatique, le planant et fluctuant Trygve Seim, et au trio d’un pianiste au long cours: Marcin Wasilewski, homme de main du trompettiste Tomasz Stanko, frère en errance de ce Young auquel on rêve de le voir un jour associé.
Michel Barbey, Le Temps