This 1978 production emphasizes what a creative player he is in his own right, inspired by the great team of players assembled for the session. […] Goodrick’s lifetime (1945 – 2022) has given his fans years of memorable listening and pleasure.
Bob Morello, Boston Post Gazette
This is undoubtably one of the most important ECM albums of its time, and indeed of anytime. […] Mick Gooderick’s importance as a guitarist, teacher, and mentor cannot be underestimated. He has taught and influenced many in his time as a tutor at Berklee and through private tuition. Never one to seek the limelight his live appearances and recording were few and far between, but when he did enter the recording studio, the resulting music was very special. […] Bringing some music with him, Goodrick’s compositions seem to suit the musicians and straight away there is a sense of unity. The opening ‘Feebles, Fables and Ferns’ recently heard on the recently released CD of the same name (and recorded a decade apart) with pianist Fred Hersch and based on the standard ‘Baubles, Bangles and Beads’ features the baritone saxophone of John Surman and superb solo from the guitarist accompanied by some expressive and fascinating drumming from DeJohnette. The long ‘In The Tavern of Ruin’ finds Surman switching to soprano with a probing solo, but again it is Goodrick’s playing that makes the ears prick up whether in his subtle accompaniment and original voicings or consistently inventive solos. […] A genuine innovator and original voice on the guitar Mick Goodrick was in danger of becoming forgotten, overwhelmed by the volume of guitarists currently active who he no doubt influenced or mentored. Wit the re-issue of this fine recording, and the aforementioned duet album with Fred Hersch, the guitarist once again should be the name on every discerning listener’s lips. Not to be missed.
Nick Lea, Jazz Views
The album displays his talents as composer and bandleader, from the playful ‘Feebles, Fables and Ferns’ (later re-recorded on his recently released posthumous duo album with pianist Fred Hersch) to the expansive group composition ‘In Passing.’ Beautifully written and stunningly performed, ‘In Pas(s)ing’ is a remarkably ego-less album for a respected musician finally given the spotlight, and is well worth the time for jazz fans, guitar nerds, and aficionados of tuneful improvisation.
Michael Toland, The Big Takeover
Das ist Urlaub für die Ohren, der warme und feinsinnige Klang betört uns von der ersten Sekunde an. ‘In Pas(s)ing’, die einzige LP des so großartigen Mick Goodrick als Leader bei ECM Records, gehört zu Recht zu den Meilensteinen des Münchner Plattenlabels. […] Goodricks Stil an der Gitarre ist alles andere als aufdringlich. Er benötigt weder Effekthascherei noch virtuoses Tempo. Stattdessen zeichnet sich sein Spiel durch Raffinesse und Zurückhaltung aus, geprägt von subtilen Schönheiten und einer achtsamen Kommunikation mit seinen Mitspielern. Besonders hervorzuheben ist das Zusammenspiel mit John Surman (Sopran- und Baritonsaxofon, Bassklarinette), das traumhafte Verbindungen schafft. Auch Eddie Gómez am Kontrabass und Jack DeJohnette am Schlagzeug erweisen sich hier einmal mehr als Meister ihres Faches. Obwohl es keiner detaillierten Analyse der einzelnen Titel bedarf – die fünf Stücke sind durchweg von gleichbleibender Genialität geprägt – möchte ich dennoch ‘Pedalpusher’ als besonderen Anspieltipp empfehlen. Hier wird exemplarisch deutlich, wie Goodricks Spielweise eine fast telepathische Verbundenheit mit seinen Partnern erzeugt. ‘In Pas(s)ing’ ist in jeder Hinsicht atemberaubend schön, verwurzelt in den Traditionen des Jazz und gleichzeitig zeitlos im Kontext moderner Musik.
Manfred Krug, Vinyl Fan
‘Pedalpusher’ opens with ‘Mr. Goodchord’s’ characteristic harmonic density, supporting Surman’s bass clarinet wanderings. The album ends with the improvised ‘In Passing,’ again anchored by Goodrick’s orchestral harmonies. The great Jack DeJohnette offers a clinic in rhythmic tension and release before the quartet slowly winds down. […] ‘In Pas(s)ing’ is at once of its time and deeply relevant to the current moment. It represents the spacious, free jazz of five decades past, but Goodrick’s powerful influence on current music makes it sound fresh and familiar.
Frank Housh, All About Jazz
Let us start with the recording itself. For this album the quality of the recording is as important as the playing. It was made at Talent Studio in Oslo by Jan Erik Kongshaug—and is typically in the style of ECM Records: spacious, detailed, each instrument given room to breathe without being isolated from its neighbor. But here it genuinely enhances the music’s atmosphere. The recording never feels artificially distant; instead, it amplifies the sense that the quartet is improvising inside a large, emotional landscape. […] Released in 1979, this is an album that has gathered a reputation over the years. Subtle and understated, ‘In Pas(s)ing’ is that rare album that rewards not just listening but the quality of attention you bring to it. Goodrick always put a special emphasis on accompaniment. His guitar tone here is beautiful and almost un-guitarish. He plays with a logic that is all his own. His phrases emerge deftly and then disappear before we have apprehended them. […] In Pas(s)ing consists almost entirely of Goodrick originals, save for the collectively improvised title piece. The compositions are modest in the best sense. They present unassuming, thoroughly considered themes that function less as showcases than as invitations. […] Ultimately, ‘In Pas(s)ing’ is less about individual virtuosity than collective intelligence. Goodrick contributes the harmonic philosophy and emotional restraint; Surman supplies the elemental force and dramatic urgency; Gómez provides melodic elasticity and lyrical grounding; DeJohnette shapes the music’s internal weather.
J. Kenny, All About Jazz
Er hat vor allem als Lehrer in Boston fast alle Großen beeinflusst, aber diese Aufnahme vom November 1978 mit John Surman an den Saxofonen, Eddie Gomez am Bass und dem Spitzenschlagzeuger Jack DeJohnette zeigt, wie kristallklar auch seine Kompositionen waren, was für ein modernes, ja pianistisches Verständnis er von Akkorden hatte, während seine sparsamen Soli den Geist des Bläsers atmeten.
Tobi Müller, Rolling Stone (German Edition)