Überall fasziniert hier besonders eines: die erzählerische Kraft des Musikers. Packend, wie Larry Grenadier die Hörer in diesen Stücken mitnimmt in immer neue Stimmungen und Nuancen. Er streicht und zupft den Bass, liebkost und fordert ihn – und spricht durch ihn. Und es entsteht ein bezwingend schöner Fluss von Gedanken und Klängen, die sich Zeit nehmen. Die Raum haben. Und ihn – ohne jede Artistik, ohne jedes Vorzeigen von Tricks oder Kniffen - wie selbstverständlich füllen, weil hier ganz großes Können in Substanz aufgeht. Kein einziger hektischer Ton – aber Stücke, die in ihrer ruhigen Unaufdringlichkeit eine eigene Magie entwickeln. Der Elefant unter den Saiten-Instrumenten: Wie fein, wie beweglich, wie elegant kann er sein! Und wie er singen kann und sich dabei selbst begleiten – ohne, dass irgendetwas fehlen würde. Ein musikalischer Hochgenuss.
Roland Spiegel, Bayerischer Rundfunk
The music […] feels complete in itself, and aglow with an integrity of purpose. The Gleaners relies on chamber-esque arco arrangements as well as sculptured pizzicato statements, always with a smart and self-contained air.
Nate Chinen, WBGO
Despite its narrow instrumental focus, The Gleaners presents a captivating study in sound, texture and compositional ingenuity.
Brian Zimmermann, Jazziz
The Gleaners proves to be worth the wait. […] it's illuminating to hear Grenadier as he executes on beautifully orchestrated ballads, spare vignettes and improvisations. As intelligent, clever and technically gifted as he is, Grenadier always puts the song first and it makes for great listening.
Karl Ackermann, All about Jazz
There is unlikely to be another solo bass record that tops this one for a long time.
Fritz Balwit, Audiophile Audition
[The Gleaners] is so sensitive, creative, and stylistically diverse that it presents perhaps the first real opportunity for such a recording [a solo double bass recording] to engage an audience beyond the standard confines of aficionados and other musicians. The Gleaners is an inner exploration articulated with uncommon generosity, disciplined artistry, and a poet's gift for illumination.
Thom Jurek, All Music
Seine erste Solo-Produktion kommt spät, doch mit ihr reiht er sich in die Tradition von Bassisten wie Dave Holland, Barre Phillips und Miroslav Vitous ein, die bei ECM legendäre Selbstgespräche herausgebracht haben. Und Grenadier muss sich vor ihnen keineswegs verstecken. […] Sieben eigene Stücke von Grenadier enthält diese splendide Aufnahme, hinzu kommen Auftragskompositionen von Wolfgang Muthspiel und je eine Herrlichkeit von Gershwin und Coltrane. Wer jetzt noch denkt, Bass sei etwas von und für Brummbären, wird hier herzhaft belehrt.
Manfred Papst, NZZ am Sonntag
The mixture of compositional aesthetics, as well as a thoughtful blend of playing techniques, make the ‘solo bass’ idea work […]. […] for listeners who love the upright bass and are willing to listen with care, this recording is a gem. It is an album for careful listening—which practice repays the effort. […] The Gleaners is a worthy addition to ECM's history of music for upright bass alone. In fact, I like more than its predecessors. It stands on the shoulders of those records and keeps reaching.
Will Layman, Popmatters
The tracks all have a certain sense to them, veering away from atmospherics more towards a strong rhythmic jolt and sense of momentum. Above all Grenadier knows how to harness tone in this cause. A handsome record, the sound production is excellent, it has a rootsy flair as well as serious intent and is a must for all students of jazz bass.
Stephen Graham, Marlbank
Das Album atmet aus dem Geist der Geschichte und verströmt gleichzeitig den eindringlichen Duft von Gegenwart. Die Arco-Stücke, häufig im tiefen Bassbauch gestrichen, sind von klassisch-lyrischer Schönheit, wobei das rasante ‚Vineland‘ als virtuoses Meisterstück und ‚My Man’S Gone Now‘ brillante Ausnahmen bilden. Dass die pizzicato gespielten Songs weitgehend auf Groove verzichten und die Musik fast ohne Overdubs auskommt, beweist die Klasse dieses Bassisten. Ein sinnliches Album.
Steff Rohrbach, Jazz ‚n‘ More
Thanks to wise architectural ideas and a dedication to pith, ‘The Gleaners’ is one of those records you’ll keep returning to. Assurance, comfort, expression, vulnerability—a manifold approach to emotion makes Grenadier’s recital an irresistible excursion. […] The bowed pieces augment the album’s textural breadth. Finding kinship in Trane’s ‘Compassion’ and Paul Motian’s ‘The Owl of Cranston,’ the bassist crafts a medley that drifts while it whirls. The title track works a facile theme the same way that Jenny Scheinman’s ‘The Lucky Hum’ or ‘Albert’ created their artful folksiness. Both string improvisers know the allure of a simple melody, and Grenadier’s savvy regarding catchiness—with a cinematic flair here and there—makes ‘The Gleaners’ all the more mesmerizing.
Jim Macnie, Jazz Times
The upright bass might not be an instrument we’re used to hearing at front of the mix. But ‘The Gleaners’, Larry Grenadier’s bold, poetic contribution to the solo bass genre, leaves no doubt that his bass belongs there. It’s a purposeful artistic vision – at points melodic, athletic and gut-wrenchingly vulnerable – that explores not only the full range of the instrument’s technical possibilities, but also the emotional range of a deeply sensitive jazz artist. […] A testament to one of our generation’s true bass craftsmen, ‘The Gleaners’ offers a pathway into a brilliant mind taking a rare and well-deserved turn into the spotlight.
Alex W. Rodriguez, Downbeat
Hier ist nichts überflüssig, und man kann Grenadier gleichsam beim Denken zuhören, ohne dass es jemals ‚verkopft‘ anmutete. Großes Kino!
Klaus Nüchtern, Falter
Though rarely featured as a solo instrument, in the right hands, the double bass is capable of an expressive range that belies its menial role as a foundational bedrock in an orchestra or group. Of available recordings in a jazz or improvised music context several of the most important examples have already appeared in the ECM catalogue possibly as a result of the label’s founder, Manfred Eicher, being a bass player before he became a record producer, indeed it is said that this album by Larry Grenadier came about as a direct result of his prompting. […]In his choice of material Grenadier proves to be something of a gleaner himself, indicative of a musical intelligence that is always searching for new sources of inspiration to turn into vessels for the expression of his command of an instrument that doesn’t readily yield its range of possibilities. As I said earlier it takes the `right hands` and when these are attached to a fertile imagination we can expect something special, like the music delivered in this intriguing recording.
Euan Dixon, Jazz Views
In die Galerie der ECM-Solobassisten gehört seit neustem Larry Grenadier, berühmt als Mitglied der Combos von unter anderen Brad Mehldau, Paul Motian, Pat Metheny, Wolfgang Muthspiel. Dass er in der Lage ist, sein tückisches Instrument zur gleichwertigen Stimme zu emanzipieren, hat er in all diesen Gruppen bewiesen. Jetzt gelingt ihm das Kunststück, ‚all alone‘ während mehr als vierzig Minuten auch Nicht-Bassisten keine Sekunde zu langweilen. Gezupft wie gestrichen ist Grenadier ein großer Geschichtenerzähler und Dramaturg, einer mit einem großen Atem, der über alle virtuosen Schnellfingerkünste in der Nachfolge von Scott LaFaro verfügt, ebenso aber über die Kunst der Pause […] Dabei ist ‚The Gleaners‘ (‚Die Ährensammler‘) kein narzisstischer Exzess, sondern ein Manifest der Bescheidenheit. Er selbst sei ein Sammler, der auflese, was in allen Windrichtungen von anderen übrigbleibe. Nur: was macht er daraus!
Peter Rüedi, Weltwoche
The first thing to say about this album is that you don’t need to be an aficionado of the double bass to enjoy it. The warmth of the recording, along with the wonderful musicality of Grenadier’s playing, make it a surprisingly accessible and rewarding 42 minutes of listening. There’s a rhythmic flow to the whole album that captures the imagination, with the bassist providing a luminous, creative soundscape of melody, texture and colour.
Mike Gates, UK Vibe
ECM Records has a long history relating to solo bass recordings. Among the artists who have gone it alone for the label are Dave Holland, Gary Peacock, Miroslav Vitous, and Barre Phillips (whose ‘Journal Violone’ from 1968 - predating ECM – is reportedly the first jazz solo bass album.) It’s a prestigious group of courageous virtuosos, and Larry Grenadier has joined their ranks. Judging from ‘The Gleaners’ he deserves the privilege.
Steve Futterman, Jazzed
Whilst many of the pieces here are extremely brief, each is fully complete in itself and there is nothing remotely extraneous across the album’s 43 engrossing minutes. Brilliantly conceived and executed from start to finish, ‘The Gleaners’ offers an exploded view an artist at the peak of his powers and makes a worthy edition to ECM’s prestigious library of music for solo bass.
Fred Grand, Jazz Journal
It’s nothing less than a masterclass in the art of double bass playing.
Charles Waring, Record Collector
The opener features sumptuous bowed lines, and the pieces then alternate, more or less, between plucked and bowed sounds, with a little of both on the multi-tracked ‘Woebegone’. There’s plenty of variation within the format, the plucked bass sometimes folksy, sometimes swinging relentlessly, the bowed work exploring all registers. Throughout there is the feeling Grenadier mentions in the notes, that solo bass music precludes excess. It’s stripped down, tightly focussed music. But there is nothing ascetic about it. This recording is as sensuous as dark chocolate melting on the tongue or sipping a glass of fine Saint-Émilion. […] Beautifully recorded by James Farber, the sound of the instrument is drop dead gorgeous throughout, and so is the music Grenadier fashions from it.
John Turney, London Jazz News
More than an album of bracing insight and invention, but one of the finest solo bass albums ever produced.
Tyran Grillo, New York City Jazz Record
With decades of outstanding work alongside some of the greatest figures in music—most notably as a part of pianist Brad Mehldau's trio—Larry Grenadier represents the gold standard of modern jazz bass, his ample discography showcasing his exemplary finesse, indefatigable swing, and purposeful support with every project. For all that, his first date as a leader is an utter revelation, a dramatic artistic statement for solo bass that rewards repeated listenings […] Much like the juxtaposition of a tree bursting with life amid a cityscape on the album's cover, ‘The Gleaners’ is a robustly organic model of sophistication and the majestic summation of a remarkable career to date, one that heralds outstanding possibilities for this now all-the-more accomplished musician.
James Keepnews, Chronogram