His finest effort yet.
Nate Chinen, New York Times
Chris Potter ist der Saxophonist der Stunde […] während er uns bei Metheny mit seiner Virtuosität und seinem Einfallsreichtum ins Staunen versetzt, präsentiert er auf ‚The Sirens’ seine lyrische Seite und die des Komponisten. […] Seine Band mit Larry Grenadier (Bass), Eric Harland (Drums) und den beiden Pianisten Craig Taborn und dem Kubaner David Virelles (hier am präparierten Klavier, Harmonium und Celesta) ist nicht minder hochkarätig besetzt wie die Unity Band und begleitet Potter mit einem frei fliessenden Puls auf dieser faszinierenden musikalischen Reise.
Stefan Künzli, Nordwestschweiz
Taking his inspiration from Homer’s The Odyssey the saxophonist has come up with eight imaginative themes that have his personal stamp all over them, songlike and robust enough to withstand some pretty tough examination from his colleagues, a prime example being the albums opener, ‚Wine Dark Sea’.
Potter’s soprano is on the fore on romantic ‘Penelope’, and the gentle ‘Nausikaa’ while the title track, ‘The Sirens’ features bass clarinet coupled with Grenadier’s full toned arco bass before giving way to the impassioned cries of the tenor. And this is where the real drama unfolds, as Potter in full cry is full of inention; His tone moving from warm and tender to daring forays into the upper register. The wonderful ‘Kalypso’ courteously offers an acknowledgement to Sonny Rollins, but throughout the tenorist is very much his own man. Mention should be given the stella rband assembled for the session, with the two keyboards of Craig Taborn and David Virelles blending seamlessly to create the colours inherent in the compositions, and Harland and Grenadier a propulsive and responsive team. Another impressive album from Chris Potter, and one that indicates a new and fruitful path for future exploration.
Nick Lea, Jazz Views
Jedes Thema der aufregenden Session klingt wie ein vollendetes Tongedicht. Das liegt an Potters gravitätischem Tenorsax-Sound, mit dem er in bewegten Chorussen den Kurs durch die ‚Wine Dark Sea’ einschlägt. In der ‚Ilias’ locken Meeresnymphen mit ihrem verführerischen Gesang die Seefahrer ins Verderben. In Anspielung darauf kreiert Potter in The Sirens auf der Bassklarinette eine Melodie, die durch ihre dunkle Tongebung einen speziellen Reiz bezieht. Das gesamte Stück klingt geheimnisvoll, zumal sich David Virelles’ auf dem präparierten Piano erzeugte Klänge dazugesellen. Eine ähnliche Bereicherung sind seine wie ein Glasperlenspiel wirkenden Celesta-Einsätze in ‚Kalypso’, die Potters lyrisches Sopransax- Spiel untermalen und sich mit Craig Taborns Pianomotiven verbinden.
Gerd Filtgen, Fono Forum
Aus dem Nichts kräuseln sich spontan Melodien zusammen, greifen nach der Ewigkeit, um sich in einem anderen Nichts wieder aufzulösen – sehr poetisch, sehr stimmungsvoll, sehr nocturn, sehr fern und doch immer ganz nah und den Bezug zum Diesseits suchend. Dieses stück jazziger Kammermusik von Chris Potter klingt wirklich nach einer mythischen, verklärten Reise […] ‚Sirens’ ist Chris Potters erstes echtes Meisterwerk.
Wolf Kampmann, Eclipsed
...ce disque, où le saxophoniste joue de toute la palette du jazz contemporain, lyrique et tellurique, plutôt platonique ou carrément épique. Unde odyssée (Homère serait derrière) aux vastes horizons, à l’image des compagnons première classe qui’il embarque (C. Taborn D. Virtelles, L. Grenadier, E. Harland).
Jacques Denis, Jazz News
Well, how brave is it to take on Homer and his Odyssey in a modern jazz interpretation? Pretty damn courageous, I’d say. [...] Potter’s saxophone, as ably supported as Ulysses by his crew, tells all these stories and more. A very serious recording but a richly beautiful one as well. And are there more of the books of the Odyssey ahead?
Brian Arsenault, The International Review Of Music
Treibende Post-Bop-Nummern wechseln zartschmelzenden lyrischen Balladen, großes Drama mit zarten Stimmungsbildern – das ECM-Debut als Leader des 42jährigen Saxophonisten Chris Potter ist so abwechslungsreich und spannend wie Homers Meisterwerk. Nachdem er den antiken Klassiker wiedergelesen hatte, schrieb Potter wie in einem Rausch innerhalb von zwei Wochen de neun Kompositionen mit Titeln wie ‚Penelope’, ‚Kalypso’, ‚Nausikaa’, ‚Wayfinder’ oder ‚the Shades’, die als Songs ohne Texte zu verstehen sind. Durch die geschickte Verschränkung zwischen komponierten und frei improvisierten Passagen bleibt den erstklassigen Musikern viel Raum, um kreative Ideen solistisch einzubringen, umwerfend ist aber, mit welcher Sensibilität sie miteinander kommunizieren.
Peter Füßl, Kultur
In setting his impressions of this great epic Greek poem to music, saxophonist Potter has come up with a collection of tunes that certainly call the listener back, not just for their strong, quickly memorable , melodic qualities but for the improvisations and group interaction they inspire in supporting musicians, Craig Taborn, Larry Grenadier, Eric Harland and David Virelles. Potter is in danger of replacing the late Michael Brecker as jazz’s saxophone pace-setter, and you’ll hear why as he absolutely flies over the rhythm section on the opening track, Wine Dark Sea, maintaining a sure sene of structure all the while. However, this album isn’t all about technique. Potter’s intention was to tell stories and he succeeds magnificently, particularly on the title track where his slightly Jewish-sounding bass clarinet melody gives way to a bowed bass solo before his own tenor takes up the narrative. A thoroughly involving listen.
Rob Adams, Sunday Herald
Familiarity with Homer isn't necessary to appreciate Potter's compositions. These mood poems, like the episodes that inspired them, contain an endlessly engaging lyrical narrative, and emotional poignancy that speaks to the universal soul. [...]Homer wrote: "Each man delights in the work that suits him best"—a truism that resonates throughout this inspired and inspiring music. The Sirens will go down as one of Potter's best, but this is assuredly a collective triumph.
Ian Patterson, AllAboutJazz
Saxophonist Chris Potter has a thick resume dating back to his first gig in 1989 with Red Rodney, including his selection as the youngest winner of the Danish Jazzpar Prize, releasing 19 albums as leader, and playing with such stars as Herbie Hancock, Pat Metheny, Jim Hall, Paul Motian, Ray Brown, John Scofield, Dave Douglas, Steve Swallow, Jason Moran, Steely Dan and the Mingus Big Band. He's led his own ensembles including the electrifying Underground and was a member of Dave Holland's famed Quintet and Big Band. Sirens is Potter's first effort as leader for ECM, and he spared nothing in securing sympathetic cohorts-Craig Taborn (piano), David Virelles (prepared piano, celeste and harmonium), Larry Grenadier (bass) and Eric Harland (drums).
‘The Sirens’ is an unusual project for Potter, a wordless song cycle inspired by Homer's The Odyssey. ‘I came up with all the music in about two weeks, writing with a theme in mind,’ Potter explains. ‘I'd re-read The Odyssey after many years and was inspired to write music with that epic, mythic mood in mind. The Odyssey is all about the big themes set in bold relief - romantic adventure and a return to home, temptation and identity, life and death… things we all deal with today. The stories are ancient, but human emotions never change.’ All but one of the ‘stories’ is from Potter; the final track is a free improvisation credited to the two pianists, Taborn and Virelles. [...]
There's plenty of fire to propel The Sirens, but here we are surrounded more by elegant tapestries and shifting textures than by hard edges. Hopefully, there will be more stories coming Potter and this exquisite collaboration.
Andrea Canter, Jazzpolice